IN CONTINUATION OF MY UPDATE ON semaglutide and tirzepatide
In a recent study published in
the journal Communications
Medicine, a group of researchers examined associations between
initiation of tirzepatide or semaglutide and
incident neuropsychiatric diagnoses in adults with obesity, compared with other
weight-loss treatments, with separate analyses for individuals with and without
type 2 diabetes.
Background
Currently, obesity affects more
than 650 million adults globally, with implications for physical and mental
well-being. People with obesity are more likely to suffer from psychiatric
conditions, including anxiety and depression, than people without obesity.
Moreover, mental illness can increase the chances of developing obesity. Newer
incretin-based medications like semaglutide and tirzepatide have changed
obesity treatment by producing substantial weight loss, but their effects on
neuropsychiatric health remain uncertain in routine clinical practice.
About the study
Researchers conducted a
retrospective cohort study using de-identified electronic health records from
the TriNetX United States Collaborative Network between January 2020 and
November 2025. Adults meeting the study’s obesity criteria, who newly initiated
tirzepatide or semaglutide, were identified and compared with matched
individuals who started naltrexone-bupropion, phentermine, or
phentermine-topiramate. The study included two separate analyses based on
whether or not the participants had type 2 diabetes, and bariatric surgery
recipients and a non-pharmacological weight-loss cohort were also evaluated as
contextual comparison groups.
To increase comparability between
treatment groups, propensity score matching was performed using demographic
features, body mass index (BMI), glycated hemoglobin (HbA1c), medical history,
co-existing treatments, healthcare utilization, and results of laboratory
investigations. Patients
with type 1 diabetes, prior bariatric surgery, history of organ
transplantation, human immunodeficiency virus (HIV) infection, and end-stage
renal disease were not included. Patients were monitored for a maximum of 24
months from treatment initiation until the initial diagnosis of
a neuropsychiatric outcome, death, loss to follow-up, or end of study.
The primary outcome was a new
diagnosis of anxiety disorder. Secondary outcomes included diagnoses of
depression, mood disorder, insomnia, broadly defined cognitive deficits, nerve
disorders, peripheral neuropathy, and substance-related disorders. Hazard
ratios with 95% confidence intervals (CIs) were obtained using Cox proportional
hazards models, adjusted for possible confounders, and various sensitivity
analyses were also performed.
Study results
Before matching, individuals
initiating incretin-based therapies differed considerably from comparator
groups, particularly regarding psychiatric illnesses and psychotropic
medication use. After matching on propensity scores, the groups had very
similar baseline demographic characteristics, cardiometabolic health issues,
laboratory measures, and health care use, allowing for more reliable
comparisons between the treatment groups.
Individuals receiving semaglutide
and tirzepatide generally had lower hazards of several recorded
neuropsychiatric diagnoses when compared to bariatric surgery recipients.
Among individuals with obesity
and type 2 diabetes, both medications were associated with lower hazards of
anxiety disorders, broadly defined cognitive deficits, mood disorders, and
depression. Similar results were seen for individuals without type 2 diabetes,
but the neurological outcomes were less consistent between the groups.
Semaglutide was associated with a
higher hazard of nerve disorders in participants without diabetes, while
tirzepatide showed lower hazards of substance-related disorders and peripheral
neuropathy compared with bariatric surgery. The negative control analyses did
not find any clinically meaningful differences, providing some reassurance
about the analytical approach.
Compared with
naltrexone-bupropion, semaglutide was associated with lower hazards of anxiety
disorders, depression, cognitive deficits, and insomnia in adults with type 2
diabetes. Tirzepatide also showed lower hazards of anxiety disorders,
depression, mood disorders, and cognitive deficits within this group.
Similar reductions were observed
among adults without diabetes, indicating that both medications were
consistently associated with lower rates of several recorded psychiatric
diagnoses than this comparator.
Among adults without type 2
diabetes, a direct comparison between tirzepatide and semaglutide showed that
tirzepatide was associated with higher hazards of anxiety disorders and
insomnia than semaglutide, while no consistent differences were observed for
most neurological outcomes after statistical adjustment. However, the authors
noted that absolute and relative estimates differed for anxiety and insomnia in
this head-to-head comparison, so these small differences should be interpreted
cautiously.
Absolute risk differences
indicated larger reductions in anxiety disorders among individuals with type 2
diabetes than among those without diabetes when tirzepatide or semaglutide was
compared with naltrexone-bupropion.
Sensitivity analyses generally
supported the primary findings. Per-protocol and as-treated analyses showed
similar directions of association for anxiety and depression, although the
strength of some associations varied depending on treatment persistence. Lower
use of psychiatric medications, particularly selective serotonin reuptake
inhibitors (SSRIs), was also observed among incretin-based therapy recipients
compared with matched comparator groups.
Subgroup analyses suggested that
the associations were generally consistent across age, BMI, and clinical
characteristics, with some stronger associations observed among older adults
and individuals with severe obesity.
Exploratory analyses generally
showed greater reductions in body weight and HbA1c over 24 months in the
incretin-based therapy groups than in the conventional anti-obesity medication
groups, although some comparisons varied by diabetes status and outcome
measure.
Additional sensitivity analyses
using stricter outcome definitions and alternative cohort criteria yielded
findings that were directionally similar, though some estimates became less
precise due to smaller sample sizes. Importantly, cognitive findings were
sensitive to outcome definition, and the broad cognitive endpoint included
codes that could reflect acute or transient altered mental status rather than
dementia or progressive cognitive decline.
Conclusion
The findings suggest that
initiation of tirzepatide and semaglutide is associated with different
neuropsychiatric outcome patterns depending on the comparator treatment and the
presence of type 2 diabetes. Compared with naltrexone-bupropion, both medications
were generally associated with lower hazards of anxiety and depression. In
contrast, tirzepatide showed higher hazards of anxiety and insomnia than
semaglutide among adults without type 2 diabetes.
These findings provide clinicians
and patients with important real-world evidence to inform treatment decisions,
while underscoring the need for continued patient monitoring. However, the
results should not be interpreted as evidence that these medications prevent
dementia, progressive cognitive decline, or psychiatric disease, because the
study relied on diagnosis codes and remains vulnerable to residual confounding
and misclassification.
In addition, as this study was
observational, prospective studies with standardized neuropsychiatric
assessments are needed to confirm these associations. Further research is
needed to understand how these medications may influence mental health outcomes
across different patient populations.
